Battle Royale: What are the legal arguments of Apple and Epic Games?
- sep
- 26
- Posted by Michael
- Posted in Okategoriserade
Where are we up to in the legal battle? And where do we go from here?
Epic Games' antitrust lawsuit against Apple is now fully up and running. If you didn't already know, Fortnite was banned from the App Store a few weeks ago, after Epic Games enabled a new way to make payments that breach App Store guidelines. A satirical video and some rhetoric later, Fortnite was banned from the App Store (and Google's Play Store), and Epic had filed a massive antitrust lawsuit against Apple.
In the first round of fighting over a temporary restraining order (TRO), a judge handed down what amounts to a split decision. Epic Games asked that Fortnite be immediately reinstated to the App Store and that Apple be prevented from retaliating by cutting off apple's developer accounts, including the one it uses to look after the Unreal Engine. The judge granted the latter but said Apple was right to ban Fortnite and that any harm Epic incurred as a result was self-inflicted.
Where next?
The case will now call again on September 28 to decide a request for a preliminary injunction. More permanent than a TRO, but less permanent than a permanent injunction, the preliminary injunction will decide the status quo whilst the case is fought. As with the TRO, two questions are at stake. Should Fortnite be allowed back on the App Store? And, should Apple be precluded from terminating Epic Games' developer accounts on iOS. The preliminary injunction will be needed by Epic to prevent Apple from taking further action because the TRO only prevents it from doing so for a short time.
So, to reiterate, the two matters at stake are:
- Should Fortnite be returned to the App Store whilst the case is fought?
- Should Apple be prevented from retaliating against Epic's developer accounts?
Epic's argument
As noted by smartphone litigation expert Florian Mueller at FOSS Patents, Epic is "going for broke." Epic is essentially seeking to argue that the motion above should be granted almost entirely because it is going to win the case. A bit like throwing a Hail Mary on your first offensive play of the game, Epic is shying away from some of its earlier arguments that stated it would suffer "irreparable harm" if Fortnite remains banned. In the earlier TRO hearing, the judge was not at all interested in the argument that a ban on Fortnite would damage Epic Games because the problem was self-inflicted.
So, in a bid to get Fortnite back on the App Store, and to defend its iOS developer accounts. Epic's primary argument is that it is "highly likely to succeed on the merits of its antitrust claims." So what are those claims?
1. Apple has a monopoly on the iOS App Distribution Market - Epic claims that the iOS App Distribution Market constitutes a product market and that because Apple only allows iOS apps to be distributed one way, through the App Store, Apple has a monopoly on this market. Epic says that Apple's market power and control over iOS give it "special access to its consumers", enabling it to ensure its consumers have no other choice where they download their apps. Epic also says that consumers face significant switching costs if they want to leave the iOS ecosystem, further tightening its grip.
2. Apple unlawfully maintains a monopoly over iOS app distribution - Epic further claims that Apple's restrictions which prevent users from downloading apps and app stores from anywhere except the iOS App Store represent unlawful maintenance of power. Apple also contractually obliges app developers to agree to distribute iOS apps solely through the App Store, eliminating competition.
3. Apple unlawfully ties the App Store and In-app purchases - Epic claims Apple has unlawfully fettered in-app purchases to its App Store, if developers want to put apps on the App Store and offer chargeable purchases, they must use Apple's in-app purchasing system, ensuring Apple gets a 30% cut. Epic says that Apple does this even though these are two separate products, as evidenced by the fact that some App Store services are exempt such as physical products like Amazon goods, or ride-hailing services like Uber. Epic says its own Epic Games Store is further proof that a company can create an app store whilst not forcing developers to use its payment system.
4. This restrains trade and helps Apple maintain its monopoly on iOS in-app payment processing - Epic states that Apple's conduct has "substantial ant-competitive effects on iOS", and that there are no procompetitive justifications for Apple's conduct.
These are the basic strands of Epic's anticompetitive arguments against Apple. It does also speak to irreparable harm whilst Fortnite is banned from the App Store, but as mentioned, the emphasis is much less significant given how the judge responded to this argument at the last hearing. Epic extends this not only to Fortnite but to its Developer Program accounts and the Unreal Engine, the threat to which it says could make existing and potential customers (such as game developers) look to alternative tools if they think the viability of the Unreal Engine is threatened.
Epic also says that Apple is harming consumers who are unable to play the game, and for many of whom iOS is the only way they can access Fortnite.
Apple's response
Apple's response to Epic is multi-faceted. In arguing that the motion to reinstate Fortnite should not be granted, Apple says that Epic is demanding that it be forced to "alter its contracts and give Epic privileges that no other developer enjoys." Apple maintains that it has exercised its contractual rights in the face of Epic's "willful breaches and intentional misconduct." Apple states that Epic will not succeed on the merits of its antitrust claims for the following reasons:
1. Epic will not be able to prove Apple has a monopoly Apple says that all of Epic's arguments hinge on the fact that the relevant "market" in the case is the iOS app distribution market, but says that Epic's notion that "the market relevant for Epic's apps is limited to distribution via iPhones—which Epic admits is the "foundation" of its antitrust argument—is meritless if not frivolous." This is because Epic distributes Fortnite on PC, Android, Xbox, PlayStation, and Nintendo Switch. Apple further notes a previous case it had against Psystar Crop. where a judge stated that a "manufacturer's own products do not themselves comprise a relevant product market."
2. The App Store and in-app purchases are not separate - Apple claims that Apple does not force developers to use IAP to have an app distributed, but that they must pay Apple's commission if they do charge for in-app purchases. It says IAPs are part of an integrated service delivered as a single transaction, not a separate product. Apple says developers are also totally free to adopt other business models that do not include in-app digital purchases, such as through advertising, sale of physical goods, and services. As Apple has frequently noted, 84% of developers pay no commission to Apple on their apps. Apple says that Epic could have "easily" chosen a different business model to monetize Fortnite without the use of in-app purchases.
3. Apple's iPhone business model encourages competition - Contrary to claims of anticompetition, Apple is set to argue that Apple's iPhone and iOS App Store actually "pro-competitive." Apple notes that the App Store facilitated $138 billion in commerce in 2019, with $116 billion going to developers. It further states Epic "has benefited hugely" from this model, earnings "hundreds of millions of dollars" from tools Apple provides to developers. Apple further states that Epic's assertion that creating the iOS platform "does not entitle Apple to compensation for app distribution and in-app payment processing services" is "absurd.
On the matter of Fornite being banned, Apple against asserts that Epic cannot argue "irreparable harm" because it is "entirely-self conflicted." From the filing:
First, every bit of harm Epic asks this Court to address is entirely self-inflicted. This Court was right when it held in its TRO decision that Epic's "current predicament" is "of its own making," and that "self-inflicted wounds are not irreparable injury."
Apple further notes it will be able to more fully explain to the court at the upcoming hearing that Apple's historical practice is to remove all affiliated developer accounts of a developer in cases such as this.
Apple also says that Epic's claims about reputational harm are hypocritical, given that Epic is engaged in a "pre-planned media blitz" including ad campaigns against Apple. Apple says that if Epic was so concerned about its reputational injury arising from the dispute, it would not be taking so much effort to publicize it.
Apple finally states that an injunction would harm the public interest, as it would signal to the entire world that developers were free to breach their contracts with Apple at will without consequence. It further notes that if it was forced to but Fortnite back on the App Store even though it doesn't comply with App Store rules, customer privacy and security would be massively at risk:
The same considerations apply with full force to Unreal Engine. If Apple is compelled to continue supporting it despite Epic's overt breach and announced intent to harm Apple on any "front" possible, Epic could use Unreal Engine as a "trojan horse" to enable developers to insert other unauthorized features that compromise customers' security and privacy into apps. For example, Unreal Engine could be used to steal from users, or misappropriate financial information, or link to an illegal currency site for payment.
Calling soon
A lot for any judge to digest, let alone us onlookers, the case will next call on September 28, where the court will try to wade through all of this to decide whether Fortnite should be returned to Apple's App Store and whether Apple should or should not be allowed to retaliate against Epic Games and its developer accounts on the platform.
Got thoughts on the case? Leave a comment or reach us on Twitter!
Senaste inläggen
- Många i Sverige drabbade av problem med Apple-ID
- Apple stoppar generativa AI-appar som används för att skapa fejkade nakenbilder
- New Apple Pencil report makes it sound like the PS5 controller – no, really
- Apple could be springing a big surprise with M4 chip debut on iPad Pro
- Apple has realized what the iPad’s best feature is after 14 years — and its Let Loose event will make it clear
Senaste kommentarer
Arkiv
- april 2024
- mars 2024
- februari 2024
- januari 2024
- december 2023
- november 2023
- oktober 2023
- september 2023
- augusti 2023
- juli 2023
- juni 2023
- maj 2023
- april 2023
- mars 2023
- februari 2023
- januari 2023
- december 2022
- november 2022
- oktober 2022
- september 2022
- augusti 2022
- juli 2022
- juni 2022
- maj 2022
- april 2022
- mars 2022
- februari 2022
- april 2021
- mars 2021
- januari 2021
- december 2020
- november 2020
- oktober 2020
- september 2020
- augusti 2020
- juli 2020
- juni 2020
- maj 2020
- april 2020
- mars 2020
- februari 2020
- januari 2020
- december 2019
- november 2019
- oktober 2019
- september 2019
- augusti 2019
- juli 2019
- juni 2019
- maj 2019
- april 2019
- mars 2019
- februari 2019
- januari 2019
- december 2018
- november 2018
- oktober 2018
- september 2018
- augusti 2018
- juli 2018
- juni 2018
- maj 2018
- april 2018
- mars 2018
- februari 2018
- januari 2018
- december 2017
- november 2017
- oktober 2017
- september 2017
- augusti 2017
- juli 2017
- juni 2017
- maj 2017
- april 2017
- mars 2017
- februari 2017
- januari 2017
- december 2016
- november 2016
- oktober 2016
- september 2016
- augusti 2016
- juli 2016
- juni 2016
- maj 2016
- april 2016
- mars 2016
- februari 2016
- januari 2016
- december 2015
- november 2015
- oktober 2015
- september 2015
- augusti 2015
- juli 2015
- juni 2015
- maj 2015
- april 2015
- mars 2015
- februari 2015
- januari 2015
- december 2014
- november 2014
- oktober 2014
- september 2014
- augusti 2014
- juli 2014
- juni 2014
- maj 2014
- april 2014
- mars 2014
- februari 2014
- januari 2014
Kategorier
- –> Publicera på PFA löp
- (PRODUCT) RED
- 2015
- 25PP
- 2nd gen
- 32gb
- 3D Touch
- 3D-kamera
- 4k
- 64gb
- 9to5mac
- A10
- A9X
- Aaron Sorkin
- Accessories
- adapter
- AirPlay
- AirPods
- Aktiv
- Aktivitetsarmband
- Aktuellt
- Alfred
- AMOLED
- Android Wear
- Angela Ahrendts
- Ångerätt
- announcements
- Ansiktsigenkänning
- app
- App Store
- Appar
- Apple
- Apple Beta Software Program
- Apple Book
- Apple CarPlay
- Apple Event
- Apple iMac
- Apple Mac Mini
- Apple Macbook
- Apple MacBook Air
- Apple MacBook Pro
- Apple Macos
- Apple Maps
- Apple Music
- Apple Music Festival
- Apple Music Radio
- Apple Offer
- Apple Online Store
- Apple Park
- Apple Pay
- Apple Pencil
- Apple Podcast
- Apple Store
- Apple Store 3.3
- Apple TV
- apple tv 4
- Apple TV 4K
- Apple Watch
- Apple Watch 2
- Apple Watch 8
- Apple Watch 9
- Apple Watch Apps
- Apple Watch SE
- Apple Watch Series 2
- Apple Watch Sport
- Apple Watch Ultra
- AppleCare
- AppleTV
- Application
- Applications
- Apps
- AppStore
- Apptillägg
- Apptips
- AppTV
- April
- Arbetsminne
- armband
- Art Apps
- Återköp
- återvinning
- Åtgärdsalternativ
- atvflash
- Audio Apps
- Augmented REality
- Back-to-school
- Bakgrundsbilder
- BankId
- Barn
- Batteri
- batteriskal
- batteritid
- Beats
- Beats 1
- Beats Solo 2 Wireless
- Beats Solo2
- Bebis
- Beginner Tips
- Belkin
- Bendgate
- beta
- Beta 3
- betaversion
- betaversioner
- bilddagboken.se
- bilder
- bilhållare
- billboard
- Bioteknik
- Blendtec
- Bloomberg
- Bloons TD 5
- Bluelounge
- Bluetooth
- Böj
- Booking.com
- Borderlinx
- bose
- bugg
- Buggar
- Buggfixar
- Butik
- C More
- Calc 2M
- Camera
- Campus 2
- Canal Digital
- Carpool Karaoke
- Caseual
- Catalyst
- CES 2015
- Chassit
- Chip
- Chrome Remote Desktop
- Chromecast
- citrix
- clic 360
- CNBC
- Connect
- Cydia
- Dagens app
- Dagens tips
- Damm
- Danny Boyle
- Data
- datamängd
- Datorer
- Datortillbehör
- Datum
- Defense
- Dekaler
- Designed by Apple in California
- Developer
- Development
- Digital Inn
- Digital Touch
- Digitalbox
- DigiTimes
- Direkt
- Discover
- display
- DisplayMate
- Dive
- Docka
- Dräger 3000
- Dropbox
- Droples
- DxOMark
- E-post
- earpod
- EarPods
- Earth Day
- Eddie Cue
- eddy cue
- Educational Apps
- Ekonomi
- Ekonomi/Bransch
- El Capitan
- Elements
- ElevationLab
- Elgato Eve
- Elgato Eve Energy
- EM 2016
- Emoji
- emojis
- emoticons
- Enligt
- EU
- event
- Eventrykten
- EverythingApplePro
- Faceshift
- facetime
- Fäste
- Featured
- Features
- Feng
- Film / Tv-serier
- Filmer
- Filstorlek
- Finance Apps
- Finder For AirPods
- Finland
- FireCore
- Fitbit
- Fitness Accessories
- Fjärrstyr
- Flurry
- Födelsedag
- fodral
- Förboka
- Force Touch
- förhandsboka
- Första intryck
- Forumtipset
- foto
- FoU (Forskning och Utveckling)
- Fource Touch
- Foxconn
- FPS Games
- Framtid
- Fre Power
- Frontpage
- Fullt
- Fuse Chicken
- Fyra
- Gadgets
- Gagatsvart
- Gamereactor
- Games
- Gaming
- Gaming Chairs
- Gästkrönika
- General
- Gigaset
- Gitarr
- Glas
- GM
- Google Maps
- Google Now
- gratis
- grattis
- Guide
- Guider
- Guider & listor
- Guld
- hack
- Halebop
- hållare
- Hälsa
- Hårdvara
- HBO
- HBO Nordic
- Health
- Health and Fitness
- Health and Fitness Apps
- Hej Siri
- Helvetica Neue
- Hemelektronik
- Hemknapp
- Hemlarm
- Hermes
- Hitta min iphone
- Hjärta
- högtalare
- HomeKit
- HomePod
- hörlurar
- htc
- Hue
- Humor
- i
- I Am A Witness
- IBM
- iBolt
- iBomber
- iBook
- icar
- iCloud
- iCloud Drive
- iCloud Voicemail
- iCloud.com
- iDevices
- IDG Play
- idownloadblog
- iFixit
- ikea
- iKörkort
- iLife
- Illusion Labs
- iMac
- IMAP
- iMessage
- iMessages
- iMore Show
- Incipio
- InFuse
- Inspelning
- Instagram-flöde
- Instrument
- Intel
- Internet/Webbtjänster
- iOS
- iOS 10
- iOS 12
- iOS 17
- iOS 18
- iOS 5
- iOS 7
- iOS 8
- iOS 8 beta
- iOS 8.1.3
- iOS 8.2
- iOS 8.3
- iOS 8.4
- iOS 8.4.1
- iOS 9
- iOS 9 beta 4
- iOS 9.1
- iOS 9.1 beta 2
- iOS 9.2
- iOS 9.2.1
- iOS 9.3
- IOS Games
- ios uppdatering
- ios9
- iPad
- iPad Accessories
- iPad Air
- iPad Air 2
- iPad Air 3
- iPad Apps
- iPad Mini
- iPad mini 4
- iPad Mini 6
- iPad mini retina
- iPad Pro
- iPados
- iphone
- iPhone 12
- iPhone 14
- iPhone 14 Pro
- iPhone 15
- iPhone 16
- iPhone 17
- iPhone 5
- iPhone 5S
- iPhone 5se
- iPhone 6
- iphone 6 plus
- iPhone 6c
- iPhone 6s
- iPhone 6S plus
- iPhone 7
- iPhone 7 display
- iPhone 7 Plus
- iPhone 7s
- iPhone Accessories
- iPhone Apps
- iPhone SE
- iphone x
- iPhone XS
- iPhone XS Max
- iPhone7
- iPhoneGuiden
- iPhoneguiden.se
- iPhones
- iPod
- iPod Nano
- iPod shuffle
- ipod touch
- iSight
- iTunes
- iWatch
- iWork
- iWork för iCloud beta
- Jailbreak
- James Corden
- Jämförande test
- Jämförelse
- Jet Black
- Jet White
- Jönssonligan
- Jony Ive
- Juice Pack
- Juridik
- Just mobile
- kalender
- kalkylator
- Kamera
- Kameratest
- Karriär/Utbildning
- Kartor
- Kevin Hart
- keynote
- Keynote 2016
- KGI
- KGI Security
- Kina
- Klassiskt läderspänne
- Kod
- Kollage
- koncept
- konceptbilder
- köpguide
- krasch
- Krascha iPhone
- Krönika
- Kvartalsrapport
- Laddhållare
- laddningsdocka
- Laddunderlägg
- läderloop
- lagar
- Lagring
- Lajka
- Länder
- lansering
- laserfokus
- Layout
- leather loop
- LG
- Liam
- Lifeproof
- Lightnigport
- lightning
- Linux
- LinX
- live
- Live GIF
- Live Photos
- Live-event
- Livsstil
- Ljud & Bild
- Logitech
- LOL
- Lösenkod
- Lösenkodlås
- Lovande spel
- LTE
- Luxe Edition
- M3
- M3TV
- Mac
- Mac App Store
- Mac Apps
- Mac Mini
- Mac OS
- Mac OS X
- Mac OS X (generellt)
- Mac OS X Snow Leopard
- Mac Pro
- Macbook
- Macbook Air
- Macbook Pro
- Macforum
- Macintosh
- macOS
- Macs
- MacWorld
- Made for Apple Watch
- magi
- Magic
- MagSafe
- Martin Hajek
- matematik
- Meddelanden
- Media Markt
- Medieproduktion
- Mediocre
- Messaging Apps
- Messenger
- MetaWatch
- Mfi
- Michael Fassbender
- microsoft
- Mikrofon
- Minecraft
- Ming-Chi Kuo
- miniräknare
- minne
- Mixer
- Mixning
- Mjukvara
- mobbning
- Mobile Content
- Mobilt
- Mobilt/Handdator/Laptop
- Mobiltelefon
- Mockup
- Mophie
- mors dag
- moto 360
- Motor
- MTV VMA
- multitasking
- Music
- Music Apps
- Music, Movies and TV
- Musik
- Musikmemon
- MW Expo 2008
- native union
- Nätverk
- Navigation Apps
- nedgradera
- Netatmo Welcome
- Netflix
- Netgear Arlo
- News
- Niantic
- Nike
- Nikkei
- Nintendo
- Nöje
- Norge
- Notis
- Notiscenter
- nya färger
- Nyfödd
- Nyheter
- Officeprogram
- Okategoriserade
- OLED
- omdöme
- Omsättning
- OS X
- OS X El Capitan
- OS X Mavericks
- OS X Yosemite
- Outlook
- Övrig mjukvara
- Övrigt
- PanGu
- papper
- patent
- PC
- pebble
- Pebble Smartwatch
- Pebble Steel
- Pebble Time
- Pebble Time Steel
- Persondatorer
- Petter Hegevall
- PewDiePie
- Philips
- Philips Hue
- Phones
- Photoshop
- Planet of the apps
- Plex
- Pluggar
- Plus
- Plusbox
- Podcast
- Podcast Apps
- Policy
- Porträttläge
- PP
- Pris
- priser
- problem
- Problems
- Productivity Apps
- Program
- Prylar & tillbehör
- Publik
- publik beta
- QuickTime
- räkenskapsår
- räkna
- ram
- RAM-minne
- Rapport/Undersökning/Trend
- Rea
- Reading Apps
- recension
- Red
- reklaamfilm
- reklam
- reklamfilm
- reklamfilmer
- rekord
- Rendering
- reparation
- Reportage
- Reptest
- ResearchKit
- Retro
- Review
- Ring
- Ringa
- Rocket Cars
- Rosa
- Rumors
- Rumours
- RunKeeper
- rykte
- Rykten
- Safir
- Säkerhet
- Säkerhetsbrist
- Samhälle/Politik
- samsung
- Samtal
- San Francisco
- SAP
- security
- Series 2
- Servrar
- Shigeru Miyamoto
- Sia
- Siri
- SJ Min resa
- skal
- Skal iPhone 6
- skal iPhone 6s
- skärm
- SKärmdump
- Skärmglas
- Skribent
- skribenter medarbetare
- Skriva ut
- skruvmejsel
- skydd
- Skyddsfilm
- Skype
- slice intelligence
- Smart
- smart hem
- Smart Home
- Smart Keyboard
- Smart klocka
- Smart Lights
- smartphone
- Smartwatch
- Snabbt
- Snapchat
- Social Apps
- Software
- Solo2
- sommar
- Sonos
- Sony
- soundtouch
- Space Marshals
- spår
- Speakers
- Special Event
- Spel
- Spelkonsol
- Spellistor
- Split Screen
- Split View
- Sport
- Sportband
- Sports Apps
- spotify
- Spring forward
- Statistik
- Steve Jobs
- Stickers
- Stockholm
- Stor iPhone
- Storlek
- Story Mode
- Strategy Games
- streama
- Streaming
- stresstest
- Ström
- Studentrabatt
- stylus
- Super Mario Run
- support
- Surf
- Surfplatta
- svenska
- sverige
- Sverigelansering
- Switch
- Systemstatus
- Systemutveckling
- tåg
- Taig
- Tangentbord
- Taptic Engine
- Tårta
- tät
- Tävling
- Taylor Swift
- Teknik
- tele 2
- Telefoner
- Telekom
- Telia
- Test
- Tid
- TikTok
- Tile
- tillbehör
- Tim Cook
- TIME
- TimeStand
- Tiny Umbrella
- Tips
- Toppnyhet IDG.se
- Touch ID
- TouchID
- tower defence
- trådlös laddning
- Trådlösa hörlurar
- trådlöst
- trailer
- Travel Apps
- Tre
- TrendForce
- TripAdvisor
- Trolleri
- trump
- TSMC
- Tum
- tv
- tvätta
- tvOS
- tvOS 9.2
- tvOS beta 2
- Tweak
- Typsnitt
- Ubytesprogram
- UE MegaBoom
- Unboxing
- Underhållning/Spel
- unidays
- United Daily News
- Unix
- Updates
- Uppdatera
- uppdatering
- Upplösning
- upptäckt
- USA
- Ut på Twitter
- utbyte
- utbytesprogram
- Utilities Apps
- Utlottning
- utrymme
- utvecklare
- varumärke
- Vatten
- Vattentålig
- vattentät
- vävt nylon
- Verktyg
- Viaplay
- Vibrator
- video
- Videoartiklar och webb-tv (M3/TW/CS)
- Villkor
- viloknapp
- Virtual Reality
- Virus
- visa
- Vision Pro
- VLC
- Volvo on call
- W1
- Waitrose
- Watch OS
- WatchOS
- WatchOS 2
- watchOS 2.0.1
- watchOS 2.2
- Webbtv (AppTV)
- wi-fi
- Wifi-samtal
- Windows
- Windows 8
- WWDC
- WWDC2015
- yalu
- Youtube
- Zlatan